Reputation Repair: How to Bounce Back from Negative Reviews in Healthcare

When someone leaves a one-star review of your practice, it’s often less about malice and more a cry for help. Whether the concern is a breakdown in communication, a billing mishap, or simply a frustrated patient, how you respond becomes the difference between a fleeting blemish and a lasting stigma on your practice’s online reputation. In healthcare, protecting your reputation in healthcare means protecting your ability to serve and grow.

Here are three key steps that separate practices that recover from those stuck-in-the-ditch ones:

‍
1. Respond quickly, personally and humanely.

‍
The research is clear: patients pay attention when a provider responds, and ignore providers who don’t. For example, more than half (51.8 %) of patients who submitted a negative online review said they had not been contacted to address their concerns.  Another study shows that the presence of a physician response significantly moderates the damage from negative reviews.

‍
A canned “thank you for your feedback” won’t cut it. Use the patient’s name if possible, acknowledge the issue (“I’m sorry you had that experience”), show empathy (“we can see how that would be frustrating”), and commit to a solution (“please reach out to our patient-care coordinator at xxx”). If the issue is legitimately resolved, you may invite the patient to update or amend their review—gently, without coercion. A resolved complaint is also an opportunity to showcase responsiveness and care.

‍
2. Recognize some people won’t ever be satisfied—and that’s OK.

‍
No matter how polished your processes, a small group may use a review as a megaphone for anger, not feedback. But the difference lies in how the public sees it. Potential patients reading the review will often distinguish between a genuine grievance and a rant. One study found that only about 4 % of patient complaint reviews explicitly cited medical treatment; 96 % focused on issues like communication or operations.

‍
When faced with a rant-type review you cannot resolve, still respond respectfully. Acknowledge the emotion, restate your commitment, and decline to argue publicly. Then move on. The lack of resolution isn’t perfect—but your public response shows professionalism and shields your broader patient experience from being defined by one outlier.

‍
3. Build a consistent review-generation process to drown out noise.
‍

The best way to soften the impact of a bad review is to have a steady stream of good ones. Because when you have 40-50 positive reviews, one or two negatives matter less. One summary puts it this way: it takes about 40 positive reviews to offset one negative review in terms of perception.
Start with processes: asking patients to review your practice after visits, making it easy and mobile-friendly, sending gentle reminders, and monitoring your profiles regularly. You’re not just collecting stars—you’re building social proof, demonstrating your commitment to care, and shaping your public image on a daily basis.
Putting it all together, the path to reputation repair is: show empathy and speed, accept the occasional irrecoverable rant, and build momentum in positive feedback. Each of those moves reinforces your online reputation and lifts your overall patient experience.

‍

‍At Swell, we specialize in helping healthcare practices elevate their online reputation, optimize patient experience surveys and strengthen employee engagement. Let us help you build systems that respond to feedback, generate consistent reviews, and ensure your brand reflects confidence, clarity and care. Contact us to learn how we can turn your reputation into one of your strongest assets.

‍